You’re cleaning out your cabinet and come across an old bottle of vitamins or protein powder. The expiration date passed months — maybe even years — ago. So you wonder: Do expired supplements still work, or should you toss them?
What the Expiration Date Means
The expiration or “best by” date printed on supplement packaging is set by the manufacturer to guarantee maximum potency and safety up to that point. It doesn’t necessarily mean the supplement becomes harmful after that date, but it may lose strength and effectiveness over time.
Unlike medications, which can degrade into toxic compounds in rare cases, most expired supplements — especially vitamins and minerals — are unlikely to be dangerous. However, they may no longer deliver the intended health benefits.
What Happens After Expiration
Here’s what could happen as supplements age:
-
Reduced potency – Vitamins like C, B-complex, and folic acid degrade more quickly, especially if exposed to heat, light, or moisture.
-
Stable but less effective – Minerals like calcium, magnesium, or zinc tend to be more shelf-stable but may still weaken over time.
-
Spoilage risk – Gummies, probiotics, and liquid supplements are more prone to spoilage, especially after their expiration date. If they smell off, change color, or have visible mold, throw them out.
Factors That Affect Shelf Life
Several conditions can shorten or extend a supplement’s shelf life:
-
Storage – Supplements last longer when kept in a cool, dry place away from sunlight and humidity.
-
Packaging – Sealed containers with desiccants (moisture-absorbing packets) help protect freshness.
-
Form – Capsules and tablets typically outlast powders, liquids, or chewable.
Should You Still Take Them?
If the supplement:
-
Looks and smells normal
-
Has been stored properly
-
Is only a few months past expiration
…it may still be safe to take — but likely less effective. On the other hand, if the product is far past its date, especially if it’s a delicate formulation like probiotics or fish oil, it’s best to replace it.
Final Verdict
Expired supplements aren’t usually harmful, but they can be a gamble in terms of effectiveness. For critical health needs — like pregnancy, chronic conditions, or immune support — fresh, high-quality supplements are always the better choice. When in doubt, check with your healthcare provider or simply invest in a new bottle.